Flowing Water Under Ice: A Hidden Danger on Simonton Lake in Elkhart, IN

Simonton Lake in Elkhart, Indiana, is a popular spot for ice fishing, snowmobiling, and winter recreation. While many residents and visitors enjoy the frozen lake, not all ice is safe to walk or drive on—especially in areas where water flows beneath the surface. Flowing water significantly impacts ice formation and strength, creating thin, weak, and unreliable ice that can be dangerous if not carefully assessed.

How Flowing Water Affects Ice Formation
1. Constant Movement Prevents Solid Freezing
Unlike still water, which allows thicker, more stable ice to form, flowing water disrupts the freezing process. Water movement beneath the ice prevents uniform ice growth, leading to thin, unstable sections. This means that even when other parts of the lake appear frozen solid, areas with flowing water can be dangerously weak.

2. Uneven Ice Thickness
Flowing water erodes ice from below, creating inconsistent ice thickness across the lake. A person may test the ice in one area and find it safe, only to step a few feet away and fall through thinner ice. This is especially dangerous near river inlets, outlets, and natural springs, where water movement is strongest.

3. Warm Water Upwelling
Some areas of Simonton Lake have underground springs that bring warmer water to the surface. This warm water prevents thick ice from forming and can create unexpectedly weak spots. Even if the surrounding ice looks thick, these hidden warm-water pockets increase the risk of breaking through.

4. Changing Ice Conditions
Ice on Simonton Lake is not static—it changes daily based on temperature, snowfall, and water movement. Even if an area was safe one day, flowing water can weaken it overnight, making previously stable ice unsafe. Rising temperatures or recent rainfall can accelerate this process, making ice conditions unpredictable.

High-Risk Areas on Simonton Lake
Certain locations on Simonton Lake are more prone to dangerous ice due to water movement, including:

• Near Inlets and Outlets: The constant flow of water prevents thick ice formation.
• Under Bridges: Moving water beneath bridges weakens ice, even when the rest of the lake appears solid.
• Near Docks and Piers: Water movement around docks often keeps ice from freezing uniformly.
• Where Streams Enter the Lake: Any spot where a creek or river feeds into the lake is high-risk for thin ice.

Safety Tips for Avoiding Flowing Water Hazards

• Check Ice Thickness Frequently: Clear ice should be at least 4 inches thick for walking and 8-12 inches for vehicles. Always test ice in multiple locations.
• Stay Away from Inlets, Outlets, and Springs: Assume any area with moving water has weaker ice.
• Look for Visual Cues: Thin ice may have darker or slushy patches, indicating weaker spots.
• Never Travel Alone: If you fall through, having a buddy can be life-saving.
• Wear a Life Jacket or Flotation Suit: In case of an emergency, this can prevent drowning.

​
Flowing water under the ice makes certain areas of Simonton Lake unpredictable and dangerous. By staying aware of where moving water exists and taking proper precautions, you can enjoy winter activities safely while avoiding the hidden dangers beneath the ice.